How accurate is Death by Lightning? Exploring facts vs fiction in the latest Netflix drama

How Accurate Is Death by Lightning?

Death by Lightning begins with a straightforward question: “Who is Charles Guiteau?” This query sets the tone for Netflix’s latest historical mini-series, blending political thriller and tragedy, while focusing intensely on historical truth.

Viewers may wonder how much of what is depicted actually happened in American history. The answer is that much of it did. Despite some added dramatic elements, the series remains largely faithful to the real events surrounding President James Garfield’s rise and sudden downfall.

However, a few artistic liberties and shifted timelines give the story a more cinematic feel, making it seem almost too polished to be purely historical.

Portrayal of James Garfield

The series shows James Garfield, played by Michael Shannon, as a modest man who never imagined becoming president. It opens with a scene of him building a table, symbolizing his preference for physical work over politics.

Garfield "was, in fact, happier on his Ohio farm than he was in Washington."

This detail is historically accurate, reflecting Garfield's true character and background.

Summary

Death by Lightning skillfully balances historical facts with some dramatization, offering a compelling yet mostly accurate portrayal of James Garfield and his time.

Would you like the summary to be more formal or conversational?

Soap Central — 2025-11-07